E-9 Foreign Worker HR Management: Key Issues and Solutions for Employers Overview

Foreign workers holding an E-9 visa play a significant role in industries such as agriculture, livestock, and manufacturing in South Korea. 

However, issues related to workplace transfers, unfair dismissal claims, and wage arrears are frequently encountered, making HR management for foreign workers a sensitive topic. This article examines the key HR management issues arising from workplace transfers and unfair dismissal claims by E-9 visa holders and suggests effective solutions.

1. Workplace Transfer Process for E-9 Visa Workers

Visa Restrictions:
E-9 visa holders are generally restricted to working at the employer that sponsored their visa. If they wish to change employers, both the current and new employers must agree, and the relevant authorities must be notified for approval.

Rewriting the Employment Contract:
When a workplace transfer occurs, the foreign worker should sign a new employment contract clearly outlining the work conditions, salary, and environment. To maintain the visa status, the transfer must be legally approved.

Limitations on Transfers:
E-9 visa holders are allowed to transfer employers up to three times within three years, with a maximum extension of 1 year and 10 months. However, transfers resulting from managerial issues or unfair dismissals are not counted toward the total limit.

2. Unfair Dismissal Claims

Lack of Clear Grounds and Procedures for Dismissal:
Foreign workers may not fully understand the reasons for dismissal, especially if language barriers exist. Employers may also fail to provide clear grounds or follow correct dismissal procedures. In many cases, workers may not realize they have been unfairly dismissed, and employers may face unfair dismissal claims despite having reached an agreement for voluntary resignation.

Unfair Dismissal Claims Process:
Foreign workers who are unfairly dismissed can file a claim with the Labor Relations Commission. However, many foreign workers face significant challenges in understanding the legal process and asserting their rights. Local foreign worker support centers often assist with filing such claims.

Employer’s Legal Response:
Employers must strictly follow legal procedures when dismissing an E-9 visa worker. To avoid future disputes, it is critical to document the worker's intentions (e.g., resignation or workplace transfer) through written confirmation, such as resignation letters or other forms of proof.

3. Main Causes of Unfair Dismissal Claims

Miscommunication:
Common issues arise from miscommunication between workers and employers. For example, a worker may express a desire to take a sick leave, but the employer interprets this as a resignation and processes it as such. Similarly, if a worker reports issues like wage arrears or dissatisfaction, the employer may mistakenly file for a voluntary resignation instead of addressing the issue. In many cases, disputes are resolved through "reconciliation," rather than legal action.

4. Other Key Issues in HR Management for Foreign Workers

Failure to Update Employment Contracts:
One common issue in managing foreign workers is the failure to update employment contracts when conditions change. Although employers often sign initial contracts for work permits, subsequent changes in job conditions or pay may not be reflected in the updated contracts. It is essential that employers regularly review and revise contracts to comply with legal requirements and avoid potential disputes.

Wage and Benefits Management Issues:
Conflicts may arise regarding wages and benefits, particularly with overtime pay, holiday work, or unused vacation compensation. Employers should issue regular payslips and maintain clear records of wage payments and benefits to ensure compliance with labor laws.

Discriminatory Treatment and Human Rights Violations:
Foreign workers who experience discrimination (based on nationality, race, gender, etc.) may claim that they are being treated unfairly compared to domestic workers. Employers must ensure equal treatment for all employees, as discriminatory behavior can lead to legal consequences and potential claims of human rights violations.

Lack of Regular Compliance Checks:
Employers should regularly review compliance with the Labor Standards Act and other relevant labor laws. This includes ensuring workers’ rights to rest periods, annual leave, and overtime. Periodic audits and training for HR personnel can help prevent legal issues from arising.

5. Conclusion

HR management for foreign workers holding an E-9 visa involves more than just managing wages and work hours. Employers must comply with legal requirements, prevent discriminatory treatment, and improve communication with workers to maintain a positive relationship and avoid conflicts. By following these guidelines, businesses can prevent HR-related issues and create a legally compliant and smooth working environment for foreign workers.

For inquiries about employing foreign workers or managing HR-related issues, 

please contact us ->>> (일대일 상담 글쓰기 > 노무법인 주로)

tel. 02-459-5453

e-mail. joolaw_hr@naver.com